217 pizzerias across 16 cities
Every pizzeria we have found in Indiana, grouped by city. Pick a city for addresses, phone numbers, hours and directions — and to switch off the national chains so only the family-run kitchens remain.
How the ranking works. Two things decide the order: the star rating a pizzeria's Google reviewers give it, and the slice ratings our own readers leave. Each side counts for as much as the number of people behind it, and the result is weighed against the Indiana average — so a handful of reviews cannot buy the top spot. National chains are not eligible. For example: Magoo's California Pizza is 4.8 on Google from 2,254 reviews. A place with the same 4.8 from only six reviews ranks below it — six opinions are not six hundred. We do not invent a rating. Until real people leave slice ratings here, a pizzeria shows Google’s number, marked as Google’s. A To Go Pizza score out of 6 🍕 appears beside a place only once our readers have actually rated it.