To Go Pizza › New York › Cicero

Pizza in Cicero, NY

7 pizzerias · 6 independent

Explore 7 listed pizzerias in Cicero, New York. Inclusion in the directory is free. Featured placements, when present, are labeled and do not change ratings. 6 are independent rather than national chains. The best rated is Lakeshore Pizza at 4.8 from 137 Google reviews. Every one has a phone number you can ring from this page.

Use the 🏠 Independent and 🔥 Wood-fired marks to narrow it down, and tap any name for the address, phone number, opening hours, menu and directions.

🏠 Independent pizzerias in Cicero

6 of them. One shop, or a handful. No national menu, no franchise book — whoever owns it is usually the one who decides what goes on a pizza.

Lakeshore Pizza

6969 Lakeshore Rd, Cicero, NY 13039
(315) 699-3223
★ 4.8 (137) 🏠 Independent
⭐ Leave a review🏪 Claim this Business Profile

Paladino's Cicero Pizza

8154 Brewerton Rd, Cicero, NY 13039
(315) 699-4004
★ 4.6 (621) 🏠 Independent
⭐ Leave a review🏪 Claim this Business Profile

Sapori By Antonio Restaurant & Pizzeria

5962 NY-31 Unit 12, Cicero, NY 13039
(315) 699-0494
★ 4.6 (436) 🏠 Independent
⭐ Leave a review🏪 Claim this Business Profile

Cicero Country Pizza

8292 Brewerton Rd, Cicero, NY 13039
(315) 699-2775
★ 4.6 (311) 🏠 Independent
⭐ Leave a review🏪 Claim this Business Profile

Twin Trees Cicero

6259 NY-31, Cicero, NY 13039
(315) 699-6422
★ 4.4 (123) 🏠 Independent
⭐ Leave a review🏪 Claim this Business Profile

Sardo's Pizza and Fish Fry

6195 NY-31 #15, Cicero, NY 13039
(315) 699-6955
★ 3.9 (216) 🏠 Independent
⭐ Leave a review🏪 Claim this Business Profile

Chains in Cicero

One of them. You know what you are getting, and sometimes that is the point.

Pizza Hut Express

8061 Brewerton Rd, Cicero, NY 13039
(800) 948-8488
★ 3.0 (14)
⭐ Leave a review🏪 Claim this Business Profile

← All cities in New York

Compare Google stars with our member report cards using the guide to pizza ratings. Read where these listings come from, report an incorrect listing, or use the pizza finder to search another area.